
The Oldest Idea In Anti-Capitalism
My Jewish friends, this post is for you. And for everyone who still thinks they can look away.
In my last posts, we connected the dots between climate, Palestine and the green transition farce. The causes change. The target never does.
Now let’s connect all of it to the ultimate scapegoat: Israel.
Because right now, a lot of people, on the far left and the far right, are blaming the West’s chaos on Israel. And very quickly, on the Jews.
There’s nothing new about this reflex. It’s the oldest idea in anti-capitalism.
An ideology that doesn’t produce wealth has to produce culprits.
Capitalism doesn’t need a scapegoat. It creates value, trade enriches both sides, the pie grows. Marxism thinks in zero-sum terms: if someone is rich, he must have stolen from someone. And when the promised wealth never arrives, someone has to be named the thief.
Marc Andreessen put it in his manifesto: a society that stops growing slides into zero-sum thinking, infighting and decay. Zero-sum is the breeding ground of every hatred.
And the first thief was named by Marx himself. In 1843, in On the Jewish Question, he wrote that the worldly god of the Jew is money. The Jew becomes the face of capital. By the end of the century, German social democrats already had a name for the reflex: antisemitism is the socialism of fools.
After that, the list of culprits never stops.
The bourgeois. Then the kulak, the peasant barely better off than his neighbor, deported by the millions under Stalin. Then the Jew again. In 1953, Stalin launches the “Doctors’ Plot” against mostly Jewish physicians. In 1975, the Soviet bloc backs a UN resolution declaring Zionism a form of racism. It is revoked in 1991, the year the USSR collapses.
Today, the word is “colonizer.”
The culprit changes. The mechanism never does.
And Israel is the perfect culprit. A rich, Western, democratic, high-tech country that turned arid land into a start-up nation. Everything anti-capitalism hates, packed into a single state. A Jewish state, on top of that. Israel has become the Jew among nations.
The irony is that you find the exact same framework on the far right.
Take Alain Soral, France’s best-known antisemitic ideologue. He claims a past in the Communist Party in the 1990s. He sits on the National Front’s central committee, founds his own movement in 2007, and runs in 2009 on an “anti-Zionist list” with the comedian Dieudonnรฉ. He has been convicted multiple times for antisemitic statements.
His worldview never really changed: a financial elite exploiting the people, and behind finance, the Jews. Soral never left Marxism. He kept the worst of it. It’s class struggle with a surname.
Like Marx, he doesn’t understand how wealth is created. So he looks for who took it. That is exactly the economic illiteracy that fueled both totalitarianisms of the 20th century. One saw the Jew behind capital. The other hunted “rootless cosmopolitans.” Both hated the market. Both needed culprits.
The day people connect the real sources, everything will make sense.
Because the real sources of evil aren’t hidden. They’re public, documented, signed. They are not a religion. Not an ethnicity. Not a secret elite pulling strings. They are ideas.
Communism. And more broadly, collectivism: the belief that the individual belongs to the group, that wealth must be seized rather than created, and that someone must always pay for the failures of the plan.
In 1944, Friedrich Hayek laid it out in The Road to Serfdom. National socialism and communism were not opposites. They were two branches of the same collectivist tree. He dedicated the book “to the socialists of all parties.”
The 20th century ran the experiment on both branches. Tens of millions dead. And every time, a culprit: the kulak, the bourgeois, the Jew.
That’s the great mistake of every conspiracy theorist. They hunt for a hidden enemy, when the real one wrote its books in plain sight.
I dare to hope the 21st century won’t make the same mistakes.
So the only fight that matters for the West today is to defeat collectivist ideas wherever they’ve taken root. In universities. In supranational bureaucracies, starting with Brussels, which still believes a continent can be planned. In the socialist wing of the Democratic Party. And in a far right that recycles Marx without even knowing it.
And yes, there are Jewish Marxists. Their ideas must be fought like those of every Marxist, of every origin. Not because they are Jewish. Because they are Marxist. That’s the whole difference between us and Soral: we judge ideas, never bloodlines.
And we know it works. Milei’s Argentina broke triple-digit inflation. El Salvador saw its murder rate collapse. When order and prosperity return, scapegoats lose their purpose.
My Jewish friends, don’t pick the wrong allies.
Every time the 20th century hated the market, it ended up looking for the Jew behind it.
Growth doesn’t need to hate anyone. That’s why they fight it.